How does the 100 point rating scale work?

If you are starting your whisky journey or new to rating on Whiskybase, this guide will help you understand the 100 point scale in a simple and comfortable way.

You do not need any whisky knowledge to begin.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

• 1. What the 100 point scale is
• 2. What the numbers usually mean
• 3. How to build your own rating style
  • Step 1: Choose your “average whisky”
  • Step 2: Compare whiskies from the same producer
  • Step 3: Keep extreme scores special
• Example: How your early ratings might look
• 4. Your rating is your own experience
• 5. Summary

1. What the 100 point scale is

The 100 point scale lets you score a whisky from 0 to 100.
A higher number means you enjoyed the whisky more.

Many respected whisky reviewers use this method, such as Michael Jackson, Serge Valentin, and Ralfy. Using the same scale helps everyone speak the same language when discussing whisky.

Whiskybase uses this scale because it offers more detail than a star rating. Even small differences in taste and quality can be shown clearly.

2. What the numbers usually mean

Here is a simple guide to help you understand the scale.

These ranges are not strict rules. They are simply a guide to help you get started.

3. How to build your own rating style

As you explore whisky, your confidence and understanding will grow. These steps will help you develop a personal rating style that feels natural and consistent.

Step 1: Choose your “average whisky”

Think of a whisky you find pleasant but not amazing.
Most members place an average whisky between 76 and 82.

Step 2: Compare whiskies from the same producer

Ask yourself whether the whisky feels better or worse than the typical releases from that distillery or bottler.
This makes it easier to adjust your score up or down.

Step 3: Keep extreme scores special

Scores below 60 or above 90 should be saved for whiskies that are truly disappointing or truly exceptional.
Using these rarely helps keep your scale meaningful.

Example: How your early ratings might look

Here is a simple example to show how someone might rate their first few whiskies.

Whisky A
You enjoy it but it feels simple.
You decide this will be your “average whisky.”
Rating: 78

Whisky B
More flavor, smoother, and more enjoyable than Whisky A.
Rating: 84

Whisky C
This whisky immediately feels special and stands out from others you have tried.
Rating: 90, because you want to keep scores above 90 for truly memorable experiences.

This approach helps your rating scale grow naturally as you discover more whiskies.

4. Your rating is your own experience

There is no right or wrong score.
Whisky tastes different to everyone, and that is completely normal.

Whiskybase does not enforce rules on how to rate.
You are free to explore, learn, and develop a personal rating style.

If you are ever unsure about a rating or want advice, the Whiskybase community is very welcoming. Many members enjoy helping others on their whisky journey and are happy to share tips and experiences.

5. Summary

If you ever need help understanding whisky ratings or want guidance as you explore, feel free to reach out. We are happy to support your whisky journey.